Why People Stuck One Hand in Their Jackets in Old Photographs
Conveying calm assurance, the practice of placing one hand inside of a top garment is ancient, dating back to before people even wore jackets, at least as we think of them.
In the 6th century B.C., it was considered rude in some Greek circles to speak with the hands outside of the clothing, especially when conducting matters of state. As Aeschines said in his famous speech Against Timarchus (346 B.C.):
And so decorous were those public men of old, Pericles [495-429 B.C.], Themistocles [524-459 B.C.], and Aristeides [530-468 B.C.] (who was called by a name most unlike that by which Timarchus here is called), that to speak with the arm outside the cloak, as we all do nowadays as a matter of course, was regarded then as an ill-mannered thing, and they carefully refrained from doing it. And I can point to a piece of evidence which seems to me very weighty and tangible. I am sure you have all sailed over to Salamis, and have seen the statue of Solon [638-558 B.C.] there. You can therefore yourselves bear witness that in the statue that is set up in the Salaminian market-place Solon stands with his arm inside his cloak. Now this is a reminiscence, fellow citizens, and an imitation of the posture of Solon, showing his customary bearing as he used to address the people of Athens.
By Aeschines’ time, however, the custom had fallen out of fashion and was (seemingly) not revived in the Western world again until around the 18th century.
In the early 1700s, portraitists like Jonathan Richardson (1667-1745) were beginning to apply painting theory to their realistic images. Identifying in his Essay on the Theory of Painting (1725) that the sitter’s general appearance (“air”) and body language (“attitude”) were the keys to an excellent portrait, Richardson and his contemporaries began looking to classical orators and the postures used in ancient statuary for their inspiration. Wishing to convey that the sitter was both of “good humor, and suitably elevated in character,” the pose of “hand-in” was soon adopted. Ironically, it became so popular among the English ruling class because (they thought) it conveyed them “in a manner deemed agreeable and without affectation.”
Godfry Kneller’s Self-Portrait (1710) was an early example of the fad, and soon the most well-known portraitists were employing the attitude. Richardson himself painted Horace Walpole (1734-35), while perhaps the most famous English portraitist, Thomas Gainsborough (1727-1788), had his “hand-in-pocket” for his Self-Portrait (1759). In fact, one fashionable portraitist, Thomas Hudson (1701-1779), used the gesture so frequently that people questioned whether or not he was even capable of painting hands.
Not solely an English fad, artists across Europe at that time used the pose, including Spain’s Francisco de Goya (1746-1828), Giacomo Ceruti (1697-1767) of Lombardy, France’s Jean-Baptiste Perronneau (1715-1783) and Jean Étienne Liotard (1702-1789) of Switzerland.
Of course, perhaps the most famous portraits where “hand-in-waistcoat” is employed are of Napoleon Bonaporte (1769-1821), including Portrait of Napoleon Bonaparte, First Counsel (1804) by Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres (1780-1867), The Emperor Napoleon in His Study at the Tuileries (1812) by Jacques-Louis David (1748-1825), and the posthumous Bonaparte Crossing the Alps (1848-50) by Hippolyte Delaroche.
The stance remained popular even with the advent of photography, and “hand-in-pocket” images can be found of American weapons inventor Samuel Colt (1814-1862), author of The Communist Manifesto Karl Marx (1818-1883), and U.S. Major General George B. McClellan (1826-1885).
The practice fell out of favor by the end of the 19th century, for the most part, although it was still occasionally used in the 20th century, including by Joseph Stalin (1878-1953) in this photograph from 1948.
If you liked this article, you might also enjoy our new popular podcast, The BrainFood Show (iTunes, Spotify, Google Play Music, Feed), as well as:
- The Origin of “Say Cheese” and When People Started Smiling in Photographs
- Who was the Woman in the Famous Great Depression Photograph and What Happened to Her?
- When People Started Wearing Clothes
- The Surprisingly Recent Time Period When Boys Wore Pink, Girls Wore Blue, and Both Wore Dresses
- When Women Started Growing Out and Painting Their Nails
- Aeschines: Against Timarchus
- Ancient Greece
- Napoleon Bonaparte
- Bonaparte Crossing the Alps
- Bonaparte, First Counsel
- Giacomo Ceruit
- Samuel Colt
- The Emperor Napoleon in His Study at the Tuileries (1812)
- An Essay on the Theory of Painting (Richardson)
- Thomas Gainsborough
- Francisco de Goya
- Hidden Hand that Shaped History
- Jean-Étienne Liotard
- Josef Stalin in uniform with hand inside jacket front, 1948
- Karl Marx
- George B. McClellan
- Jean-Baptiste Perronneau
- Re-dressing Classical Statuary: The Eighteenth-Century “Hand-in-Waistcoat” Portrait (Meyer)
- Rhetorical Action in Ancient Athens (Fredal)
- Why is Napoleon depicted with his hand in his coat?
- Why was Napoleon Usually Painted with A Hand in His Coat?
 Meyer at 47
 Meyer at 49
|Share the Knowledge!|
Hmmm. Sounds like something that should be revisited in net photos somewhere. 🙂
I think it’s quite strange looking. In that portrait of Napoleon, it looks like he has an itch, not like he’s regal and assured.
I always assumed it was because hands are REALLY hard to draw.
That was my impression too!
I thought hiding hand may symbolize hidden meaning. In the same manner as nude picture, IMHO.
Whenever I see pictures of Napolean I always think he must’ve been like Geoffrey on Game of Thrones. Small in size, huge in ego, always smirking with self-importance and being nasty to people. The hand in the waistcoat just seems to add to the arrogance.
Actually Napoleon was about average in size for his time. He was 5 foot 7 inches. In French units (which were different from English) he was 5 foot 2 inches and hence the false belief.
Don’t know if it’s true or not but I’ve heard it is something to do with Free Masonry. The work of hidden hands or something to that effect.
Yes, we know in the Napoleon, Stalin, and Marx photos, they were using the hidden hand of Free Masonry.
I’m wouldn’t conclude that every photo I see with a person doing that is a Free Mason, but it’s very common for them to do so.
It’s the hidden hand in Free Masonry, we know that’s why Napoleon, Marx, and Stalin did it.