When Aluminium Cost More than Gold

Karl Smallwood 8
aluminium

Aluminium is literally one of the most common elements on Earth.  So how did it come to be that aluminium cost more than gold? Was it similar to how the relatively common and easily acquired mined diamond came to be seen as valuable in the last century due to strict control of supply to consumers and some of the best marketing the world has ever seen? (For reference, the cost of mining a 1 carat diamond is about $50, though it sells for drastically more than that, even low quality ones for industrial use.  On the high end, suitably high quality ones will sell for, on average around $25,000 once cut and polished, generally by cheap labor in places like China.)

The simple answer is that although aluminium makes up about 8% of the Earth’s crust, it has never been known to occur in its metallic form anywhere on Earth. Instead, aluminium appears mainly as a chemical compound across the globe, for example inside potassium aluminium sulfate.

Before aluminium was discovered, or even theorised, so called “alum compounds”, like potassium aluminium sulfate, have been used extensively since antiquity for everything from leather tanning to fire-proofing. In fact, potassium aluminium sulfate (colloquially known as potassium alum) is still used today in things like aftershave and baking powder and most awesomely of all, in its crystal state it can be used as a “deodorant rock” that you rub on yourself to eliminate body odour.

Now, at first glance it would seem like these chemical compounds are referred to as “alum” because they contain aluminium, but this isn’t the case. The word “Alum” is the colloquial name given to a wide range of compounds that don’t necessarily include aluminum, for example chromium potassium sulfate which is commonly shortened to chrome alumThe word aluminum itself is a derivative of the the word “alum”, not the other way around.

It is commonly held that aluminum wasn’t theorised to exist until around 1807 when a chemist, Sir Humphrey Davy, argued that alum was the salt of a yet undiscovered metal, a metal Davy wanted to call “alumium”. However, there’s some debate amongst the scientific community about whether Davy was truly the first person to make this leap, because 30 years prior in 1778, the French chemist, Antoine Lavoisier, posited in his landmark book “Elements of Chemistry” that what he called “argilla” (aluminium oxide) could exist as a solid metal in theory, but that the technology of the day couldn’t separate the strongly bound oxygen atoms. In fact, argilla is tentatively listed as an actual element in Lavoiser’s original draft of his table of elements.

Aluminium as we know it today was first created in a lab by Hans Christian Oersted by heating aluminium chloride with potassium amalgam in 1825. In honor of Davy’s work which had inspired Oersted’s experiment in the first place, this new metal was dubbed “aluminium”.

The flecks of metal that Oersted produced using this method were so small and impure that a proper analysis of the metal was impossible.

Two years later, Friedrich Wöhler entered the aluminum manufacturing scene and developed a new way of isolating aluminium in its powdered form by improving upon Oersted’s original experiment. Even then it took another 18 years for enough of the metal to be produced for scientists to properly study its properties, and it wasn’t until 1845 that aluminium’s remarkable lightness was noted.

Nine years later, in 1854, Henri Sainte-Claire Deville developed a way of producing the metal on a much larger scale with the use of sodium, allowing, for the first time in history, kilograms of the metal to be produced at a time. For comparisons sake, it had taken Wöhler years to produce the same amount of aluminium Deville could produce in a single day.

A year later, in 1855, 12 small ingots of aluminium were displayed at the “Exposition Universelle” a huge French exhibition organised at the bequest of French emperor Napoleon III. Almost immediately after the exhibition, demand for this magical metal sky-rocketed. Its shininess combined with its almost ghostly lightness compared to other metals made it an ideal metal for jewellery and it wasn’t long until the French elite were wearing broaches and buttons made of the aluminium.

This passing fancy that the upper echelons of society had with aluminum infuriated Deville to no end because he felt that the metal had significant practical applications to benefit the masses, not just to be used as a curiosity to be flaunted by the elite.

One person who shared Deville’s vision was Emperor Napoleon III himself who granted Deville a virtually unlimited budget to study and produce the metal long before the exhibition. Napoleon had hoped that this new metal could be used to produce lightweight weapons and armor for his army. Although a few helmets were produced, the sheer cost of refining the metal shelved the plan indefinitely.

Frustrated, Napoleon III had his supply of aluminium melted down and pressed into cutlery. As the oft-repeated story goes, Napoleon III was rumoured to have eaten off of the aluminium plates while his guests had to make do with ones made of gold. Whether that story is true or not, at this point aluminium really was harder to get hold of than gold and the price reflected that, despite its prevalence in the Earth compared to gold.

All of that changed in 1886 when it was discovered (twice) that you could easily obtain oodles of aluminum using electrolysis. The discovery was made by Paul Lois Toussaint Héroult and Charles Martin Hall at almost the same time in both France and America, totally independent from one another. For this reason, the process (which is still used today) is referred to as the Héroult/Hall process in honor of both of them.

Two years after this, it was discovered by Karl Bayer that aluminium oxide could be made very cheaply from bauxite. As a result of both of these things, the price of aluminium plummeted by 80% overnight. In a few short years, aluminium went from being literally the most expensive metal on Earth to the cheapest. For reference, in 1852 (before the Héroult/Hall process), aluminium sold for upwards of $1,200 per kilo. By the start of the 20th century, that same amount of aluminium cost under a dollar.

If you liked this article, you might also enjoy:

Bonus Facts:

  • If you’re wondering why we used “aluminium” throughout this article instead of “aluminum”, it’s not a typo, though we do make a fair amount of those; so I don’t blame you if you thought that. And it’s not because we enjoy antagonizing Grammar Nazi’s ;-), though we do. It is simply because in The International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry the standardized spelling of the word is “Aluminium,” contrary to what you’ll often see, particularly in America.
  • While it’s commonly touted that De Beers massively hoards diamonds to artificially inflate the price, this isn’t as much the case today as it was a few decades ago.  As their virtual monopoly has slowly slipped away, they’ve instead started selling off their stock piles and, to help control supply, simply cut production in times of low demand.  For instance, in 2009 they cut their mining efforts in half due to the recession hurting sales significantly.  The rest of the industry followed suit and the price of diamonds remained high.
  • A high quality, clear, synthetic 1 carat diamond costs about $2,500 to manufacturer to a state where it’s ready to be sold to consumers as jewellery.  The average consumer price tag for that diamond in 2011 was $3,500. As mentioned, a 1 carat, high quality, mined diamond costs drastically less to get to a state suitable for selling as jewellery, yet retails for about $25,000.

Expand for References

Share the
Knowledge!
facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinteresttumblrmailfacebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinteresttumblrmail
Print Friendly
Enjoy this article? If so, get our FREE wildly popular Daily Knowledge and Weekly Wrap newsletters:

Subscribe Me To:  | 
Check Out Our New Book!»

8 Comments »

  1. Laurel Bill May 13, 2014 at 8:52 pm - Reply

    Wow, from $1,200 down to $1 per kilo … proof that the price of progress can plummet! Very informative article – thanks!

  2. Kevin September 26, 2014 at 3:17 pm - Reply

    Additionally, the cap of the Washington Monument which was finished in December of 1884, was made of cast aluminum (no extra “i” here in the States).

    The following from JOM:

    Aluminum was not the first choice for the cap. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers requested a small metal pyramid, preferably made from copper, bronze, or platinum-plated brass. It was suggested that aluminum be used instead use for its conductivity, color, and the fact that it wouldn’t stain. With a quote of $75 the Corps agreed.

    Several attempts at casting with the normal sand method failed and an iron mold was made and the casting was successful. Weighing in at 100 ounces and standing nine inches tall, it was the largest piece of cast aluminum that had ever been created at the time.

    It sat for two days in the window of Tiffany’s in New York City, displayed like a precious jewel. Later put on public display on the floor, visitors were allowed to carefully step over so they could tell their friends that they had walked “clear over the top of the Washington Monument.”

    The bill presented for the pyramid was $256.10 instead of the $75 bid. A subsequent audit brought the price down to $225.

    Intended as the apex of a lightning rod, the cap turned out not to be up to the task. In June 1885, lightning struck the monument and cracked the north face of the spire just under the capstone. As a result it was surrounded by a crown of gold-plated copper bars.

    A 1934 rehab of the monument’s exterior found another flaw in the pyramid. Repeated lightning strikes had blunted its tip and pieces had melted and re-fused to the sides. The promise that the pyramid would not tarnish was good, however, and inscriptions made on the metal 50 years prior were still readable.

    On the east facing side of the Washington Monument is says “Laus deo” meaning “Praise be to God.”

    The west side reads: “Corner Stone laid on bed of foundation, July 4, 1848. First stone at height of 152 feet laid August 7, 1880. Capstone set December 6, 1884.

    The north side reads: “Joint commission at setting of capstone. Chester A. Arthur. W.W. Corcoran, Chairman. M.E. Bell. Edward Clark. John Newton. Act of August 2, 1876.”

    The south side reads: “Chief engineer and architect, Thos. Lincoln Casey, Colonel, Corps of Engineers. Assistants: George W. Davis, Captain, 14th Infantry. Bernard R. Green, Civil Engineer. Master Mechanic: P.H. McLaughlin.”

    I’m surprised the the man who convinced the USACOE into using aluminum and did the casting got no mention. It was William Frishmuth, the only U.S. aluminum producer at that time.

    • Kevin September 26, 2014 at 3:21 pm - Reply

      Oops. Bad editing. Only some of that info came from JOM. The rest came from Wikipedia, mentalfloss, Snopes, and the National Park Service.

      My bad.

Leave A Response »