Why Asparagus Makes Pee Smell
Today I found out why asparagus makes pee smell.
The smell comes from the way certain chemical compounds in asparagus break down inside people’s bodies. This is why cooking asparagus in various ways does not result in the same smelly byproduct; the specific digestive enzymes that break down the compounds in the asparagus to produce the smell aren’t present until you eat the asparagus.
As to this specific resulting chemical compound that ends up causing the smell, it has long been thought that it is from methanethiol. Methanethiol is a colorless gas which smells a bit like rotting cabbage. It is composed primarily of sulfur, but also includes hydrogen and carbon.
More recent research by Robert H. White from the University of California proposes an alternative theory. White used gas chromatography-mass spectrometry to try to identify the cause of the smell and he concluded that it was actually from the s-methyl thioesters- specifically s-methyl thioacrylate and s-methyl thiopropionate. Thioesters, like methanethiol, are primarily sulfur based except are formed from sulfur bonding with an acyl group.
In either case, the ability of a particular person to produce the necessary smelly compound in their urine after digesting asparagus was thought to be a genetic trait unique to only some humans until relatively recently. Recent research done in France, China, and Israel, all independently showed this is not the case. Rather, all humans appear to produce the smelly compound, but only some humans can detect the smell; the ability to detect the smell or not is a genetic trait. Further, according to the study done in Israel, only about 22% of people have that genetic ability to smell the odor from the urine of people who have recently eaten asparagus.
If you liked this article, you might also enjoy our new popular podcast, The BrainFood Show (iTunes, Spotify, Google Play Music, Feed), as well as:
- How the Calorie Content in Food is Determined
- What the Color of the Twist Tie on Bread Packaging Signifies
- Why a Baker’s Dozen is 13 Instead of 12
- Why Garlic Makes Your Breath Smell Bad
- The Red Juice in Raw Red Meat is Not Blood
- The presence of methanethiol in the urine of someone who has recently eaten asparagus was first discovered by M. Nencki in 1891.
- The chemical compounds which cause the smell in urine from eating asparagus can appear as soon as fifteen minutes after a person eats asparagus.
- Asparagus belongs to the same family as lilies. Once the asparagus buds start to open, the shoots become unpalatable and woody, so typically only young asparagus shoots are used for eating, making all asparagus eaters baby killers. 😉
- Methanethiol can commonly be found in the blood and brain of humans and various types of plant tissue. It can also be found in various types of nuts and cheeses.
- Methanethiol is also one of the major causes of bad breath.
- Tomatoes and Asparagus are good plants to grow near one another due to the fact that tomatoes keep the asparagus beetle away and asparagus repels certain types of root nematodes that are bad for tomatoes.
- Asparagus is an extremely healthy little plant. It contains quite a bit of calcium, zinc, magnesium, fiber, thiamin, riboflavin, rutin, niacin, folic acid, iron, phosphorus, potassium, copper, manganese, chromium, and selenium. It also contains good amounts of vitamin A, B6, C, E, and K.
Quotable Asparagus Quote:
- “A few stems of asparagus eaten shall give our urine a disagreeable odor; and a pill of turpentine no bigger than a pea shall bestow upon it the pleasing smell of violets.” -Ben Franklin
|Share the Knowledge!|
Nice article. I had always heard that only some people (mainly Europeans) produced the odor, but the idea that everyone produces it, but only some can detect it……..very interesting
I have always eaten asparagus. But just today had the terrible smell in my urine for the first time. Had to google it because it kinda scared me. This is the first time I have eaten it since giving birth to my 3rd child a couple months ago & I wonder if that could have changed something in my body. having babies does do crazy things to our bodies!
I have always avoided eating asparagus for this reason. Strong smells of any kind bother me a lot, and asparagus pee makes me gag, it smells so awful. There are plenty of other healthy veggies out there!
for me, I ate a large helping of asparagus, and the smell started in a few hours, and it persisted for @ 2 days… I accurately assessed the source, but it WAS surprising.
I have grown asparagus for 2 years now. When we eat my asparagus, there is NO odor. What could that mean?
That you are one of those who cannot smell it 🙂
I have a new revelation on this stinky relationship. I have recently emarked on a clean eating, detox, whole health restoration. Since the beginning of March, I eat non-labeled foods: veggies, eggs, fermented foods, kombucha and distilled water. I just had asparagus for the first time since this journey began and had no stinky urine. Every time before this dietary change, I had been “blessed” with well-known odor.
I suspect now that either a reduction in toxins, an optimally performing digestive tract, a higher level of digestive enzymes help to neutralize the sulfuric reaction.
The body is a remarkable creation and designed to heal itself given the right fuel and protections from synthetic exposures. I am awestruck at how much it tells us when we are attentive.