There Once was a 17 Year Old Girl Who Struck Out Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig Back to Back

Daven Hiskey July 12, 2012 20

Jackie Mitchell Shaking Hands with Babe Ruth

Today I Found Out there once was a girl who struck out Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig in succession.

What’s even more impressive about that was neither Ruth nor Gehrig managed to even get the bat on the ball when they swung.  Ruth swung and missed twice before taking a called third strike.  Gehrig swung and missed three times, striking out on just three pitches.  Unfortunately for her, what she got for her efforts was to be promptly banned from Major and Minor league baseball by Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis.

The woman was Virnett Beatrice “Jackie” Mitchell, one of the first female professional baseball players in history.  Mitchell’s baseball life started out about the same time she was old enough to pick up a ball.  Her father initially taught her to play baseball, but she got more instruction from a soon to be famous neighbor.  Seeing her interest in the game and learning of her dream to someday play in the Major Leagues, her neighbor, minor leaguer (and future MLB Hall of Famer and the greatest strikeout pitcher of his era), Dazzy Vance, taught her a few tricks, including supposedly how to throw what would become her signature pitch, a devastating sinker.

Fast forward to the age of 17 and Mitchell was making a name for herself playing around with various teams, including striking out nine consecutive batters at one point. She drew the attention of Joe Engle, owner of the Chattanooga Lookouts, while she was attending a baseball school’s pitching camp in Atlanta, Georgia in March of 1931.  He spotted her and signed her to a contract to play for the New York Yankee’s AA minor league baseball club, the Lookouts.  It was while with the Lookouts that she got a chance to face off with the game’s best.

The Chattanooga News on March 31, 1931 scouted her thus:

She uses an odd, side-armed delivery, and puts both speed and curve on the ball. Her greatest asset, however, is control. She can place the ball where she pleases, and her knack at guessing the weakness of a batter is uncanny …. She doesn’t hope to enter the big show this season, but she believes that with careful training she may soon be the first woman to pitch in the big leagues.

After the previously scheduled exhibition game was rained out, on April 2, 1931, Mitchell got her chance in front of 4,000 spectators, though few saw her as anything but a side-show.

The Yankees will meet a club here that has a girl pitcher named Jackie Mitchell, who has a swell change of pace and swings a mean lipstick. I suppose that in the next town the Yankees enter they will find a squad that has a female impersonator in left field, a sword swallower at short, and a trained seal behind the plate. Times in the South are not only tough but silly.”  The New York Daily News, April 2, 1931

The starting pitcher of the day was former Cardinal and Tiger, Clyde Barfoot.  He was removed after just two batters after giving up a double to Earle Combs and a single to Lyn Larry. In came the lefty Mitchell, whose extreme side arm delivery made it particularly hard for lefties to hit off of her.  The first batter she faced was none other than the Sultan of Swat himself, Babe Ruth.  The first pitch she threw him was high for a ball.  The next two, though, Ruth swung and missed at.  She then threw a sinker low and away that caught the edge of the strike-zone, which he took for strike three.  He reportedly had a few choice words for the umpire while walking away that were “not meant for a lady’s ears”, giving  his thoughts on the pitch being called a strike.

Next up was “Iron Horse” Lou Gehrig.  She didn’t mess around with him, throwing him three consecutive sinkers, with him swinging and missing at every one.  The next batter, Tony Lazzari, fared better, though he didn’t manage a hit.  Instead, Mitchell ended up walking him, at which point she was pulled from the game.  The Yankees would go on to win 14-4.

After the game, Ruth stated, “I don’t know what’s going to happen if they begin to let women in baseball. Of course, they will never make good. Why? Because they are too delicate. It would kill them to play ball every day.”

Apparently Commissioner Landis felt the same way.  Within a few days, he officially voided her contract and banned her from Major and Minor league baseball, stating that baseball was “too strenuous” for women to play (though “The Queen of Baseball”, Lizzie “Spike” Murphy, should have given him the notion that this wasn’t true with her 17 year illustrious baseball career; more on her in the Bonus Facts below).  Despite this individual banning, Major League Baseball wouldn’t officially ban women until June of 1952, a ban that stood for 40 years, until it was repealed when the Chicago White Sox drafted Carey Schueler in the 43 round of the draft for the 1993 season.

Not everyone was quite so down on Mitchell’s efforts.  The New York Times had this to say after her performance against Ruth and Gehrig:

Cynics may contend that on the diamond as elsewhere it is place aux dames. Perhaps Miss Jackie hasn’t quite enough on the ball yet to bewilder Ruth and Gehrig in a serious game. But there are no such sluggers in the Southern Association, and she may win laurels this season which cannot be ascribed to mere gallantry. The prospect grows gloomier for misogynists.

Of course, she was never given the chance to show what she could develop into against the world’s best, so no such gloomy prospect arose.  After being unjustly kicked off the Yankee’s AA farm club, Mitchell continued her professional career playing on various barnstorming teams, including the famed “House of David” team, famous for their long beards (Mitchell would sometimes wear a fake beard to match them).  She quit baseball at the age of 23, though, after becoming fed up with people ignoring the fact that she was a genuinely good lefty pitcher, and instead treating her like a side-show, including once being asked to pitch from the back of a donkey in a match.

If you liked this article and the Bonus facts below, you might also like:

Bonus Baseball Facts:

  • The first known woman to face MLB players in a game was Lizzie “Spike” Murphy, “The Queen of Baseball”, on Aug 22, 1922.  She played in a charity game with the American League All-Stars as a first basemen against the Red Sox.  Murphy was described by the owner of the famed semi-pro Boston All-Stars, which she played on for several years, as “…worth every cent I pay her. But most important, she produces the goods. She’s a real player and a good fellow.”  Lizzie also later played in a National League All-Star game, making her the first person (man or woman) to play on both league’s All-Star teams.  She also later played in a Negro League game.  She didn’t just make money playing, but also would sell autographed post cards at the games, which sometimes garnered her more than what her share was for playing in the game (which incidentally was already more than her fellow teammates, as she had once held-out from playing because she felt, correctly, that more fans were coming to see her than the other players, so her share should be higher).  She played a full 17 seasons before retiring in 1935.
  • After Jackie Mitchell retired, she went and began work at her father’s optometry office.  When the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League was formed during WWII (Mitchell was 29 years old at the time), she was asked to come out of retirement to pitch, but declined the offer.
  • Mitchell was not actually the first female player to be signed to play in the Minor leagues.  The first was Lizzie Arlington (real name Elizabeth Stroud) in 1898.  She played in one Class A Atlantic League game.  Atlantic League President, Ed Barrow, had this to say about Lizzie’s sole outing, “For four or five innings, she had plenty of stuff and control… She knew all the fundamentals of the game, having been taught by fellow townsman, old Jake Stivetts, who pitched many years in the National League in the 1890s.”  She gave up six hits and three earned runs that game, which her team won 18-5.  After Lizzie was done pitching, she switched to playing second base for the rest of her sole game in the minor leagues.  On the other side of the game, she collected two hits at the plate.
  • Alta Weiss

    Another early female phenom was 17 year old Alta Weiss who began pitching in 1907.  She reportedly had a good fastball, curve, knuckleball, sinker, and spitball, which she was very shy about admitting she had, due to it being “indelicate” for a lady to mention.  She made sure she had plenty of saliva by chewing gum during the games.

  • Weiss pitched around for various teams in high school before graduating.  In order to make sure she’d be allowed to continue to play, her father bought a semi-pro baseball team for her to play on, renamed the Weiss All-Stars.  She also pitched at Wooster Academy in college, where she earned a Doctor of Medicine degree, the only female to do so in the year of her graduation at that school.
  • In 1924, Dazzy Vance finished the season with 262 strikeouts.  This would be impressive even today, but at the time it was mind boggling. His K-rate was at 21.5% that season.  The league average was 6.9%.  His final strikeout total was more than any other two National League pitchers combined that season.  The next closest to him were Burleigh Grimes (135 strikeouts), and Dolf Luque (86 strikeouts).  To put it another way, Dazzy Vance was responsible for 1/13th of all strikeouts in the National League that season.
  • Dazzy Vance retired with 2045 strikeouts in just 11 seasons, which even beyond that being an insane amount over that span in the era he pitched in, was even more remarkable considering that his first full time stint in the Majors didn’t come until he was 31 years old (having only managed about 33 innings in MLB while in his 20′s, which he mostly spent in the minor leagues).
  • According to a stat called K%+, [(pitcher's K% / League Average K%)*100], Dazzy Vance was the greatest strikeout pitcher of all time relative to what the league was doing when he pitched.  Of the five best K%+ seasons any pitcher has thrown, Vance holds four of the top five spots, including the top three.  The lone other pitcher to make that list was Lefty Grove in 1926.  Pedro Martinez is at number 6 for his 37.5% strikeout rate he put up in 1999.

Expand for References

Enjoy this article? If so, get our FREE wildly popular Daily Knowledge and Weekly Wrap newsletters:

Subscribe Me To:  | 
Print Friendly
Check Out Our New Book and "Nerdy Stuff" TIFO Shop! »

20 Comments »

  1. Michael Dale July 12, 2012 at 9:37 am - Reply

    I wrote a play about Jackie Mitchell that was produced in Baltimore as part of the 100th Anniversary of Babe Ruth’s birthday. http://articles.baltimoresun.com/1995-02-08/features/1995039179_1_mitchell-chattanooga-lookouts-dazzy-vance

  2. Mushyrulez July 12, 2012 at 4:39 pm - Reply

    wear* a beard, not where one.

    I’m not sure I understand why the commissioner would ban her from playing baseball. I mean, if you’re going to ban one athletic woman ‘because it’s too strenuous’ (pffft, yeah right), why wouldn’t you ban all of them?

    Sexism, I don’t understand it >_>

    • Daven Hiskey
      Daven Hiskey July 13, 2012 at 12:17 am - Reply

      @Mushyrulez: As always, thanks for catching the typo. And I agree, you can’t look for reason and logic in the realm of blatant sexism, or racism for that matter.

  3. Andy from Beaverton July 17, 2012 at 10:41 pm - Reply

    Here’s another picture of that event:
    http://p2.la-img.com/46/2359/1016934_1_l.jpg

  4. Jimbo September 1, 2012 at 11:03 am - Reply

    Old news. Are you guys just 15 years old?

  5. Allison S October 1, 2012 at 5:42 am - Reply

    Hi Daven – great article. I was wondering where you found the image of Jackie and Babe Ruth and if it is in the public domain – if not, where could I go to acquire the rights to use it? Thanks!

    • Daven Hiskey
      Daven Hiskey October 1, 2012 at 12:57 pm - Reply

      @Allison S: Generally if I didn’t include a reference for the image source in the References, it means it is in the public domain or I paid for its use. If I do include the image source link, it means that’s all that was required to use that image. In this case, I didn’t include the source nor paid for it, so I’d assume that means when I did the search for the copyright, it was free to use. So from that, I’d assume it’s copyright free as I’m extremely careful about not using copyrighted images. However, I just did a quick search and couldn’t find that particular image anywhere except on Today I Found Out, so I can’t verify that. I did find this image in the library of Congress, which is very similar with her shaking hands with Babe Ruth. It is part of the New York World-Telegram & Sun Newspaper Photograph collection and according to the library of Congress website “NYWT&S staff photographs are in the public domain per the instrument of gift…” It’s very possible that’s also where I got the above image too, but whatever the case, the alternate image linked too then it would seem is in the public domain. Hope that helps.

Leave A Response »