Was the Character of Sherlock Holmes Based on a Real Person?
In 1887, Doyle published the novel “A Study in Scarlet.” It was the first work to star Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson. It was also the first record of a magnifying glass being used as a tool of investigation. “A Study in Scarlet” didn’t attract much attention (and neither did its sequel, “The Sign of Four.”) but in the July 1891 issue of “The Strand Magazine”, Doyle published the first short story starring Holmes. That’s when the detective began to take off in popularity. Even early on, readers wanted to know who was the basis for this new type of crime fighter. Doyle couldn’t have just conceived this eccentric, brilliant, logical character out of thin air, right? After more than a century since Sherlock Holmes made his first appearance on paper, evidence points to Holmes being based on primarily two individuals, as well as, perhaps, the author himself.
At the young and impressionable age of 18, Doyle was studying to be a physician at the University of Edinburgh in 1877. It was a professor by the name of Joseph Bell that drew Doyle’s attention immediately. Dr. Bell’s lectures were bombastic, entertaining, and fascinating. Using his amazing deductive abilities, Dr. Bell would make immediate conclusions about his patients that were often spot-on.
According to Doyle himself, as written in his autobiography, Bell’s “strong point was diagnosis, of not only disease, but of occupation and character.” In a famous example, also accounted in Doyle’s autobiography, a man stepped forward to Bell without giving any information about himself. After a good eying over, Bell gave this conclusion about the man he’d never met before:
Well, my man, you’ve served in the army… Not long discharged… A Highland regiment… A non-com officer… Stationed at Barbados…
Bell was correct on all points. He explained how he did it as follows,
You see, gentlemen, the man was a respectful man but did not remove his hat. They do not in the army, but he would have learned civilian ways had he been long discharged. He has an air of authority and he is Scottish. As to Barbados, his complaint [why he was visiting the doctor] is elephantiasis, which is West Indian, not British, and the Scottish regiments are at present in that particular island.
Conan Doyle said of such displays of Bell’s, “To his audience of Watsons, it all seemed very miraculous until it was explained, and then it became simple enough.”
During Doyle’s second year, Bell “singled” him out and made him his outpatient clerk, which meant he took basic notes of the patients who came in and presented them to Bell. Essentially, he became Bell’s Watson. Ten years later, when Doyle put pen to paper, this unique and wildly fascinating skill-set, to take trivialities and turn them into broader accurate conclusions, embodied itself in Sherlock Holmes.
Doyle freely admitted this. In an interview later in life, according to the biography “Teller of Tales: The Life of Arthur Conan Doyle,” Doyle exclaimed, “Sherlock Holmes is the literary embodiment, if I may so express it, of my memory of a professor of medicine at Edinburgh University.” Further, in a letter to Bell, Doyle told him, “It is most certainly you I owe Sherlock Holmes.”
While there were major elements of Dr. Joseph Bell in Sherlock Holmes, he wasn’t the only inspiration. The famed Edinburgh native forensic scientist, public health inspector, and dissector of human bodies, Henry Littlejohn is also credited for giving Holmes some of his personality. Littlejohn was prominently involved in the investigations of any accident, tragic death, or murder that took place in Edinburgh in that day. Helping pioneer the use of fingerprinting and photographic evidence in criminal investigations, Littlejohn was revolutionizing the way cases were cracked right when Doyle was conceiving Holmes in the 1880s and 1890s.
During the time Doyle was writing “The Final Problem” in 1893, the Ardlamont murder trial was taking place. Alfred John Monson was accused of shooting his twenty year old student, Cecil Hambrough, during a hunting trip. The defense claimed that Hambrough had “accidentally” shot himself in the head. According to the Edinburgh News, Littlejohn testified that the position of the wound, the scorch marks from the bullet, the damage to the victim’s skull, and even the smell of the victim indicated the contrary, that this was murder.
Interestingly enough, Dr. Bell was brought in as an expert witness and using his considerable deductive powers ultimately agreed with Littlejohn. In the end, the jury came back with a verdict of not guilty, but Doyle used this trial and the forensic science of Henry Littlejohn as inspiration for a part of the character of Sherlock Holmes.
And finally we have Doyle himself. Bell once wrote a letter to Doyle stating, “You are yourself Sherlock Holmes and well you know it.” To illustrate, in December 1908, Marion Gilchrist was beaten to death during an armed robbery. A Jewish German immigrant was accused and then convicted of the crime. In 1909, he was sentenced to death. The following year, Scottish lawyer William Roughead wrote “The Trial of Oscar Slater,” where he laid out the case that Slater was innocent.
In 1912, in hopes of getting Slater a retrial and acquitted, Arthur Conan Doyle wrote his own synopsis “The Case of Oscar Slater,” in over a hundred pages painstakingly highlighting details and circumstances that proved Slater’s innocence, not the least of which was that the hammer found in Slater’s trunk, thought to be the murder weapon, was “an extremely light and fragile instrument, and utterly incapable in the eyes of commonsense of inflicting those terrific injuries which had shattered the old lady’s skull.”
Of course, something of a “chicken and the egg,” it is not entirely clear if Sherlock Holmes inspired Doyle’s own sleuthing or Doyle’s deductive abilities and passion for the subject helped inspired Holmes. Either way, thanks in part to Doyle, Oscar Slater was acquitted and freed in 1928.
As for the name, “Sherlock Holmes” it is thought to have been taken from two sources – “Holmes” from the prominent, and fellow doctor, Oliver Wendell Holmes and “Sherlock” from Doyle’s favorite musician, Alfred Sherlock.
- Sherlock Holmes Never Said “Elementary, My Dear Watson”
- The Unmasking of Moriarty
- The Large Number of Human Remains Found In Ben Franklin’s Basement
- Sherlock Holmes’ Mail
- What Started the “Cops Eating Donuts” Stereotype
- By the late 1890s, Dr. Bell had earned quite a reputation as an investigator. So much so, in fact, that when a series of murders of “ladies of the night” went down, the police called in Bell to help. This became the infamous Jack the Ripper case. According to a November 2011 Irish Examiner article, Bell even came up with the name of a man he suspected, but, as of the writing of the article, that name has never been released
- Doyle would continue to write adventures for Sherlock Holmes until 1927 and would pass away from a heart attack in 1930.
- The Real Life Inspiration for Sherlock Holmes – Neatorama
- Joseph Bell – Wikipedia
- Dr. Joseph Bell – The Real Sherlock Holmes – Sherlockian.com
- Did Sherlock Holmes Really Exist – Straight Dope
- The Real Life Sherlock Holmes: A Biography of Joseph Bell (The True Inspiration of Sherlock Holmes and the Pioneer of Forensic Science – Absolutecrime.com
- Sherlock Holmes – Wikipedia
- Arthur Conan Doyle – Wkipedia
- The enduring popularity of Sherlock Holmes – Oxford University
- Sherlock Holmes’ Dr Watson was ‘based on Dundee doctor’ – BBC News
- The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes: The Complete Short Stories By Arthur Conan Doyle
- Fiction imitates real life in a case of true inspiration – Irish Examiner
- Memories and Adventures By Arthur Conan Doyle
- Edinburgh’s Henry Littlejohn was also inspiration for Sherlock Holmes – Edinburgh News
- The Strange Case of Oscar Slater – Wikipedia
- The Case of Oscar Slater By Arthur Conan Doyle
- The wide world of Sherlock Holmes – The Sherlock Holmes Society of London
|Share the Knowledge!|