The Story of Pasteurization and How It Changed the World
In the mid-19th century, French scientist Louis Pasteur made a discovery that has reverberated through the ages. Perhaps working at the behest of Emperor Napoleon to figure out why wine and beer sometimes soured during fermentation, he found out that this was due to unwanted microorganisms, or “germs,” converting the alcohol into acetic acid. This produced the sour or vinegary taste that we associate with “bad” beer and wine. So, never wanting to leave anyone with a bad drink, he performed a series of tests, including the gradual heating and rapid cooling of the liquids until the offending germs were neutralized. This process eventually was named after its inventor, pasteurization.
Today nearly every liquid sold in stores are pasteurized to prevent the growth of bacteria and the potential for illness due to these unwanted microorganisms. Due to its organic and nutrient rich nature, milk is one of the most susceptible liquids to this and only pasteurized milk is considered safe by the FDA, much to the chagrin of raw milk enthusiasts. However, there is good reason for concern here. Even with modern best practices, it’s impossible to produce sterile milk and from flora of the teat canal or udder to fecal soiling to water used to clean the milking equipment, various microbes will find their way into the milk, not all of them harmless. For centuries, milk borne illnesses, from tuberculosis to salmonella, typhoid fever, diphtheria, and many others, killed millions of people every year. Even as recently as the early 20th century, cow milk was responsible for approximately one quarter of all food borne illnesses. In contrast, today, only about 3 people die from milk-related sickness per year in the United States, thanks in large part to pasteurization. Here now is the history and science behind why milk pasteurization works and why this process continues to save millions of lives every year 154 years after it was first officially discovered.
Humans have been consuming animal milk products since at least 7,500 years ago, despite not widely developing the gene mutation to properly digest milk outside of childhood until around a thousand years later. The gene that facilitates the production of lactase in the human body, necessary for processing the lactose in milk- see What Causes Lactose Intolerance, typically gets switched off in adolescence. Thanks to the rise of dairy as a significant nutrition source, initially largely in cheese and yogurt-type substances that could be widely consumed due to low lactose content and had better shelf life, those who had a genetic quirk allowing them to produce lactase into adulthood flourished, and this mutation quickly spread throughout a relatively large percentage of the human population over the centuries. By 4,000 BCE (six thousand years ago), a dairy economy existed in central Europe, Asia and ancient Egypt, and with it came disease.
Sicknesses resulting from tainted food have a long history of being an equal opportunity killer. There’s speculation that Alexander the Great died of Salmonella resulting from tainted water, food or, possibly, milk. King Henry I of England may have died from eating bad eels. Scholars think that the first Jamestown settlement may have withered away thanks to a Salmonella outbreak. “Milk Sickness,” resulting from drinking the milk of a cow that has eaten the plant White Snakeroot, killed Abraham Lincoln’s mother. President Zachary Taylor could have died from drinking iced milk. Point being, food-related illness was a rather common occurrence prior to Pasteur’s innovation, especially milk specific ones.
So how did Pasteur come up with his momentous innovation? In 1854, Pasteur joined the University of Lille as professor and dean of the science faculty. It was here that Pasteur first took up the problem of alcoholic drinks turning sour. In 1856, after being commissioned by the father of one of his students, M. Bigot, to discover what was ruining a certain beet root alcohol, Pasteur examined samples under the microscope and discovered not only spherical yeasts, but also a rod-shaped microorganism, Acetobacter aceti, which it turns out converts alcohol to acetic acid.
Methodically and systematically experimenting with both lactic and alcoholic fermentation, Pasteur concluded that fermentation was not the result of a spontaneous generation of chemical reactions by enzymes (the then-majority view), but rather the work of these microorganisms.
In 1857, Pasteur returned to the École Normale as director of scientific studies and continued his research on the problem. Notably, on April 20, 1862, he completed his first test of boiling and then cooling wine to kill the souring bacteria. At about this time, Emperor Napoleon III commissioned Pasteur to save the entire French wine industry, which had become overrun by “diseases” that caused the wine to be sour or bitter. In about 1863, Pasteur inspected a variety of wineries and came to the conclusion that “there may not be a single winery in France, whether rich or poor, where some portions of the wine have not suffered greater or lesser alteration.”
Continuing his research into heating the liquid, Pasteur, who patented his heating and cooling process in 1865, discovered that the wine could be saved from souring and the original flavor preserved by heating it to a mere 50-60 degrees Celsius or 122-140 degrees Fahrenheit. Quickly adopted by the wine industry, the general pasteurization process was not widely applied to milk until man years later, to the doom of many.
It should be noted, however, that like nearly every innovation, Louis Pasteur did not discover this process in a vacuum. As with almost every apparent giant leap forward, closer examination almost always reveals centuries of gradual progress and forward steps towards this revelation. For instance, some historians believe that a process similar to pasteurization may have existed as far back as 11th century China. In an attempt to preserve wine, the Chinese would fill hot clay jars with fresh wine, cover with leaves, seal with mud and, then, bury in the cool soil. The first documented process of pasteurization (even though it wasn’t called that at the time) was in 16th century Japan in regards to soy sauce. In order to ship it to Europe without it spoiling before it got there, the Japanese devised a process of boiling it in a iron pot, funneling it into bottles and immediately sealing them.
Even immediately prior to Pasture, there were a number of European scientists who helped pave the path to discovery. A Italian priest and scientist named Lazzaro Spallanzani realized that “a significant degree of heat” could be used to kill microbes, then reappearance could be prevented by “hermetically sealing” the jar (as opposed to cork, “which is very porous”).
Parisian chef Nicolas Appert won a cash prize from the French military for his work in providing safe, boiled, hermetically-sealed jars of preserved food to the army. (See: The Can Opener Wasn’t Invented Until 48 Years After the Invention of the Can) Using the money, he opened the world’s first food bottling factory in 1812, where he canned and boiled all types of food (including milk). His method consisted of boiling the glass bottle in much hotter water and for much longer time that Pasture would later deem necessary. Due to this, the preserved food would often have its taste altered and the glass bottles sometimes broke. A few years later, Englishman Peter Durand devised a iron can with a thin layer of tin around the exterior that could withstand the boiling process better. While Spallanzani, Appert and Durand all understand this worked, they didn’t really understand the nuts and bolts of why. In 1862, Louis Pasteur answered this question.
While the science behind pasteurization may have been relatively unknown in the mid-19th century, a basic understanding of biology helps explain it. Bacteria are single-celled organisms with a cell envelope, the cytoplasm (stuff inside of the cell like ribosomes, chromosomes, enzymes, etc.) and the flagella (the part that allows the cells to attach to other things). When the temperature gets hot enough, the enzymes inside of the cytoplasm chemically change shape and are no longer able to work properly. This essentially makes the entire cell unable to function. Heat can also destroy the cell envelope, which further damages the cells.
Once the offending cells are dead, it is just as important to make sure nothing can enter back in. That’s why jars, cans and anything pasteurized needs to be hermetically sealed or refrigerated (which doesn’t kill cells, but slows their growth) immediately after being heated for maximal shelf life.
As with other product, the pasteurization process in milk is specifically tweaked to kill most offending bacteria in the liquid, though to preserve flavor, the milk is typically not heated high enough to kill all microbes and occasionally post-pasteurization contamination also occurs. Since the milk is not hermetically sealed, these microbes still happily feed on things in the milk and multiply. Refrigerating it simply slows this process down, but doesn’t prevent it. When milk goes bad (turns sour), it means that enough bacteria has grown in it to ferment a certain amount of the lactose, which cause the sour smell. While slightly spoiled milk won’t taste good and could make one sick, the smell usually comes prior to the milk being really harmful and, potentially, deadly. In other words, the smell is a precursor warning sign.
In the century and a half since Pasteur made his discovery, pasteurization of milk and many other liquids and foods has saved many millions of lives, altering human history since in unknown ways. Who knows- given the large number of lives saved in the interim, if not for this process, one of your direct ancestors may not have existed, and hence, neither would you.
If you liked this article, you might also enjoy our new popular podcast, The BrainFood Show (iTunes, Spotify, Google Play Music, Feed), as well as:
- Why Milk is White
- How One Man’s Attempt to Create the Philosopher’s Stone Out of Human Urine Led to the First Element Discovered Since Ancient Times
- Why Do Americans Refrigerate Their Eggs and Most Other Countries Don’t?
- Why is Cheddar Orange When Milk Is White?
- Is it Safe to Eat Cheese Rinds?
- “Louis Pasteur” – Chemical Heritage Foundation
- “Milk pasteurisation and safety: a brief history and update” – World Organization for Animal Health
- “SPOILED ALCOHOL AND LOUIS PASTEUR” – Today I Found Out
- “What is pasteurization and how does it work?” – UNC Biology
- “Acetic acid” – New World Encyclopedia
- “Milk-borne infections. An analysis of their potential effect on the milk industry” – US National Library of Medicine National Institutes of Health
- “A History of Beer and Brewing” – Royal Society of Chemistry, Ian Spencer Hornsey
- “History of Soybeans and Soyfoods in China and Taiwan, and in Chinese” By William Shurtleff, H.T. Huang, Akiko Aoyagi
- “The Dangers of Raw Milk: Unpasteurized Milk Can Pose a Serious Health Risk” – FDA
- “THE IMPORTANCE OF PASTEURIZATION FOR THE SAFEGUARDING OF OUR MILK SUPPLY” – National Center for Biotechnology
- “Holy Cow! First Cheesemakers Date Back 7,500 Years” – Livescience.com
- “Archaeology: The milk revolution” – Nature.com
- “History of Cow’s Milk from the Ancient World to the Present” – ProCon.org
- “Milk of Nonhuman Origin and Infectious Diseases in Humans” – Oxford Journals
- “Bugs Through the Ages: The Foodborne Illness Fight” – Food Safety News
- “Milk Sickness” – National Park Service
- “The Life of Pasteur, Volume “1 By René Vallery-Radot
- “Biographical Dictionary of the History of Technology” edited by Lance Day, Ian McNeil
- “Nicolas Appert (c1750 – 1841)” – Brooklyn College
- “CANNING AND THE TIN CAN” – Engines of Invention
- “What made our milk go bad?” – Science World at Telus Science Museum
- Drinking Raw Milk
|Share the Knowledge!|
Hmm. Perhaps I’m an oddity, but ever since I was a small kid, I could always taste when milk was about to go bad a few days before anyone (including me) could smell it.
I tend to think pasteurization is just another step along the path to creating a world of germaphobes. Much like the overuse of antibiotics, not all bacteria are bad. Pasteurization kills ALL the bacteria. Not just the bad ones. We pasteurize everything, whether it needs it or not. How do we know if this saved the lives they are saying it did? Just cuz the internet says so, doesn’t mean it’s so. People living in a sterile environment don’t turn out well. Kids need to play in the dirt and be exposed to germs. We don’t need all the exposure to antibiotics/sterile everything that we are getting. It’s like people trying to figure out that recess is a good thing. Sedentary is bad. Fat in avocados is good. Sugar is bad. The quantities of sugar given to our children in a day is baffling. Then, they don’t want to let them go out to recess. And, then they are baffled that the children are hyper and behave badly. Rant over.
I totally agree with what you’ve said, but pasteurization IS beneficial to people. I live on a dairy farm drinking unpasteurized milk every day. My body has become used to it even being lactose intolerant. We should become exposed at a young age yes, but there are people who’s bodies cannot handle those bacteria. They are allergic or have some sort of internal conflict that doesn’t allow them to process those bacteria. It’s not that they’re germaphobes (even though I do agree to that at some extent) it’s that their well being is at stake.
Your conclusions about saving zillions of lives is flawed in many ways. It does not take into account the nutritional superiority of raw milk. Also it concludes that data about deaths from bad milk before pasteurization applies to the modern world. Raw milk today is produced in a far more sterile environment than pasteurized milk. So tell your boss the dairy industry you did the best you could to stamp out raw milk.