How Fluorescent Lights Work and Why They Are Sometimes Noisy
Comprised of a sealed tube coated on the inside with a phosphor powder and filled with (usually) argon and a tiny bit of mercury, the way in which fluorescent bulbs produce light is extremely fascinating.
While the underlying physical mechanisms in the fixture and bulb can vary a bit in design, in a nutshell a fluorescent light works via two electrodes at either end of the tube emitting electrons as they heat up. Eventually, an arc is created (via varying mechanisms depending on the fixture and bulb design) with the electrons shooting across the bulb through the ionized gas from one electrode to the other; as they move through the tube, the tiny bit of mercury in the bulb is vaporized and as the electrons collide with its atoms, it excites the electrons in the atoms to higher energy levels. However, this higher energy level is unstable and post-collision, as the electrons rapidly return to their original energy level, they release photons, albeit mostly ultraviolet (UV) light that we humans cannot see. Not a very useful light source at this point!
The photons in the UV light, however, in turn excite the electrons in the phosphor that is coating the bulb, similarly causing them to move away from their nuclei to a higher state; the phosphor electrons then quickly return to their original state, at which point they also release energy in the form of photons, but this time mostly in the human visible spectrum, creating the bulk of the visible light that makes these bulbs useful in office buildings the world over.
Now to the buzzing- Absent preventative measures, the current in the fluorescent tube would rise to dangerous levels owing to the fact that the electrical resistance of the ionized gas in the tube drops progressively as it heats up. So without something put in place to stop the current rising too much, this would be a cascading problem. Eventually, it could well flip your circuit breaker or the bulb could explode. Whatever the case, your lights would quickly stop working.
To manage that, fluorescent bulb fixtures are equipped with a ballast of some sort. This ballast classically comes in the form of an iron core wrapped in copper wire. The result is a device that slows the current’s growth, keeping it at a safe level for the bulb to operate efficiently. Important to the discussion of buzzing is that the electricity energizes the ballast into producing a magnetic field. This is, in fact, how this type of ballast works in the first place- as more current is passed through, the magnetic field gets bigger, opposing the change in the current flow and thus slowing its growth enough for the alternating current (AC) to switch directions, with it dropping to zero and going back up in the opposite direction in the process.
Standard alternating current rates are usually 60 Hz a.k.a. 60 cycles per second (such as in the United States) or 50 Hz (such as in the U.K.). Aptly named, for half of an AC cycle, the current’s charge moves in one direction, and for the second half, the charge moves in the other.
All of this switching back and forth further affects the ballast’s electromagnetic field, since each time the current switches direction (every half cycle), the polarity of the magnet also switches; so, since the electromagnet is fluctuating at twice the frequency of the AC current, its flicker rate is at 100 Hz or 120 Hz, depending on what country you’re in.
During these fluctuates in magnetic field, the ballast’s core is physically squeezed and released in a process called magnetostriction that, at a frequency of either 100 Hz or 120 Hz, produces the infamous buzz.
Of course, not all fluorescent bulb fixtures’ buzzes are alike, and this is due to differences in the fixture’s ballast type, size, how the ballast is mounted, fixture design and the degree to which the ceilings, walls, sheet metal, etc. muffle or amplify the sound.
Such a common nuisance, the industry publishes “sound ratings” for ballasts, and even recommends in which settings different ratings are appropriate. For example, those ballasts with an “A” rating are the quietest (20-24 decibels), and they are recommended for libraries, churches, reception areas and in TV and radio stations, while only a “C” level (31-36 decibels) is recommended for a “general office area,” and retail stores can get by with “D” ratings (37-42 decibels).
For those who hate the buzzing (or perhaps have issues with migraine headaches being induced by the fluorescent bulbs and their flickering light), electronic ballast (as opposed to the old school magnetic ones) are available and are even quite common today, such as generally found in Compact Fluorescent bulbs (CFLs). These ballasts typically operate at a drastically higher rate than 100 Hz or 120 Hz, usually in excess of 20,000 Hz. It should be noted, though, that if you switch to one of these electronic ballasts in your older fluorescent light fixture (something that is surprisingly cheap to do), you do need to swap out your fluorescent bulbs to a variety that is rated to work with your new ballast.
If you liked this article, you might also enjoy our new popular podcast, The BrainFood Show (iTunes, Spotify, Google Play Music, Feed), as well as:
- What Causes the Clicking in Your Car’s Turn Signal
- Why Do Drawn Hearts Look Nothing Like Real Hearts?
- Why Do We Call Parents “Mom” and “Dad”?
- Why Do Other People’s Farts Smell Worse?
- Why Do Men Snore More Than Women?
- Peter Cooper Hewitt is credited with jump-starting the fluorescent light bulb. Although both Thomas Edison and Nikola Tesla played around with fluorescent lamps in the late 19th century, it was Hewitt who created the first bulb that agitated mercury vapor with an electrical current in a tube regulated by a ballast. Casting a weird blue-green light, it didn’t catch on. However, by the late 1930s, lighting companies in the U.S. had produced commercially viable options, and by the 1950s, fluorescent lights in larger operations had become common.
- Fluorescent moved into the home in the mid-1980s with the advent of compact fluorescent light (CFL) bulbs, although at $25-$35 per bulb and an inability to fit well into existing fixtures, they didn’t become popular until recent years. Today, with improved design and at a cost below $2 per bulb, CFLs have become much more common, though (often) cheaply made integrated electronic ballasts notoriously see these bulbs have drastically smaller lifespans than the estimates on the labels.
- Considered the bulb of the future, light emitting diodes (LEDs) are also becoming more popular. In 2012 alone, nearly 50 million LED bulb replacements produced an annual energy savings of about $675 million and that number just keeps going up and up every year.
- Sam’s F-Lamp FAQ
- An Alternating Current
- ELI5: Why do fluorescent lights make noise?
- Fluorescent Ballast
- Fluorescent Light Problems
- History of the Light Bulb
- Negative and positive cycle of AC current
- Silencing the Buzz
- Why Black Lights Make Things Glow
- Why Do Fluorescent Lights Make that Buzzing Noise?
- Why Do Fluorescent Lights Buzz?
|Share the Knowledge!|
Quoting from the first paragraph of the article: “… the way in which fluorescent bulbs produce light is extremely fascinating.”
Those words should have been qualified by the addition of a phrase — e.g., “… is extremely fascinating” TO SOME PEOPLE (such as the author of the article).
If a survey were taken, I think that it would find that the majority of people do not care about “the way in which fluorescent bulbs produce light” — but only that they DO produce light.
I also think that only a tiny minority of people could even UNDERSTAND how “fluorescent bulbs produce light” — at least from the extremely complex explanation given in this article.
J. F. Gecik, who peed in your cornflakes?
I found it quite an easy explanation to understand and I’m a salesman. Perhaps you’re just not very bright? (That was a light bulb pun…)
What a miserable response to reasonably well presented article.
I happen to have a degree in Electrical and Electronic Engineering, so the principle of the fluorescent light (both old and new) is hardly a mystery to me, but that knowledge does not render it any less fascinating.
To this day, I love to read alternative descriptions of the process, and find that little details noted by later writers can be revealed, compared to earlier work or descriptions.
I would also describe this article as anything but ‘extremely complex’, or even ‘complex’, as most of the exlanation is expressed in plain, if technical, English, and does not descend into physics, or even quantum physics, to describe the energy levels involved in the emission of visible photons.
Keep up the good work TiFO, and don’t let the sourpuss’s of the world get you down,
Worked for me and sent my mind spinning off into different directions (the sign of a good article, in my opinion). Though I do prefer incandescents and just heating a filament up in a vacuum.
For what it’s worth, I remember the green first-effort florescent lights. Dad was a first-adopter and tester for any gadgets found in nerd magazines. He had it in his workroom for a long time.
Enjoyable article, as always! (love this site)
article off course is gud. but this JF GRECIK….I HAVE ALREADY WARNED THAT HE’S STILL ON MEDICATION, AND NOT ALLOWED TO MINGLE IN PUBLIC. HE’S A DANGEROUS PSYCHOPATH
I didn’t think it would be, but this is an interesting article. I have a fluorescent light in my basement that buzzes. Now that I know that this means there is a problem with the ballast, rather that I can get a quieter ballast I will call an electrician to make the switch. Thanks for posting.