Gun “Silencers” Don’t Make Them Anywhere Near Silent
Myth: Gun silencers make guns nearly silent.
“Silencers”, also known as “suppressors”, on guns don’t make them anywhere near silent. Silencers primarily only suppress the noise due to the pressure wave from the rapidly expanding propellant gases. This is only a portion of what makes a gunshot loud. The primary other source of noise in a gunshot is the sonic crack created by the bullet (for bullets that exceed the sound barrier, which is a large majority, unless they are modified to specifically be subsonic).
Other typically minor noise makers from the gunshot are the mechanical action; the sound of the bullet striking the target; and the flight noise of the bullet itself, which typically is only audible if the bullet comes relatively close to the person hearing it (depends on the caliber of bullet for how close that needs to be). The mechanical action can be quite loud on some types of fire arms, such as a Sterling Submachine Gun, which produces over 115 dB from the firing mechanism alone. The sound of the bullet striking the target can range from mostly in-audible to every bit as loud as the original gunshot.
How Much Sound Do Gun Silencers Actually Suppress
Modern day silencers typically can reduce the noise about 14.3-43 decibels, depending on a variety of factors, such as whether it’s a subsonic bullet or not; length of the barrel/silencer; etc. The average suppression level, according to independent tests done on a variety of commercially available suppressors, is around 30 dB, which is around the same reduction level of typical ear protection gear often used when firing guns.
That’s actually pretty significant considering the decibel system is a logarithmic scale; so, for example, 200 dB is 1000 times louder than 100 dB, not double, and a reduction of 40 dB is more like 1/100th of the original sound. However, for most commercially available fire arms and cartridges, this ends up only reducing the noise level to somewhere in the range of 130-150-ish dB for a supersonic cartridge and 117-130-ish dB for a subsonic cartridge. For reference on just how loud that is, an ambulance or police siren is typically between 100-140 dB. So this isn’t exactly the “whoosh” sound Hollywood depicts. Given that hearing loss can occur as low as 85 dB, it’s typically recommended that even with a silencer on a fire arm, that the shooter still wears some sort of hearing protection.
Why Use a Gun Silencer
So if they don’t make them anywhere near silent, why do people use them? It turns out, there are a lot of advantages to silencers, particularly for military usage, including:
- A typical reduction in recoil of around 30%, which increases accuracy and reduces firing fatigue on the person shooting.
- Drastically reduced flash, which can be a huge advantage for military personal, particularly in night operations or for snipers. By getting rid of most of the flash, firing won’t reveal your position from a visual standpoint. This can also be a critical feature if firing around explosive gases, particularly if, before firing each round, you put a piece of tape over the silencer opening to help prevent the gasses from entering the barrel of the gun.
- Silencers help significantly in masking the position of snipers, not just because of getting rid of the flash, but also for audible reasons. Snipers can effectively mask their position by positioning themselves such that the bullet will pass by large hard objects, which will reflect the “crack” sound from the supersonic bullet much more effectively than the “bang” sound from a non-suppressed shot. This will make it impossible for an observer to tell which direction the shot came from, because it will sound like it’s coming from every direction in a perfectly chosen environment. Wolves actually use a similar technique in modulating their howls to make it sound like there is a huge pack of wolves surrounding something, instead of just one or two.
- Suppressors change the perceived sound of a gunshot enough that most people wouldn’t recognize it as such, particularly in a city environment where there are numerous ambient noises.
- Firing an unsuppressed gun in a small closed area, such as a bedroom or the like, can permanently damage hearing due to the noise being reflected back at the shooter at close range; this can also disorient the person firing the weapon. Using a silencer significantly reduces this risk.
How Gun Silencers Work
Gun suppressors work primarily by slowing the release of the propellant gases, resulting from firing a bullet, and converting some of the noise energy to heat. The latter method is achieved by trying to trap or direct the sound through specially designed chambers or baffles; the sound is then ultimately converted to heat in these chambers. The former method is achieved by expansion of the cavity the air is being rushed through, typically by just making the chamber diameter bigger than the barrel’s diameter and by creating turbulence as the air rushes through the suppressor.
Some of the most advanced suppressors will also try to get rid of some of the sonic crack by either shifting the phase of the sound, to get it out of human range, or reflecting it back onto itself, to try to cancel it out (frequency shifting and phase cancellation). However, neither of these methods are terribly effective, to date. The phase cancellation is particularly difficult because of dealing with a wide range of sound waves, rather than pure tones. Silencer manufactures claim to have effective phase cancellation, but, to date, this isn’t backed up by any real independent scientific evidence and seems to be more just a marketing tool.
If you liked this article, you might also enjoy our new popular podcast, The BrainFood Show (iTunes, Spotify, Google Play Music, Feed), as well as:
- Hollywood Medical Myths Part 1: Shocking Someone Who Has “Flat-Lined” Can Get Their Heart Going Again
- The Evolution of the Squirt Gun
- How the Gun on the Original Duck Hunt Game Worked
- Although snipers can use a silencer and large solid objects to help reflect the sonic crack to mask their location, the U.S. currently has a “Boomerang” system, which deploys a series of microphones around a potential sniper target area. This system can almost instantly locate the origin of any gunshot within the system’s sensor range.
- The first silencer was invented by Hiram Maxim, in 1910. Maxim supposedly got the idea for a gun silencer after flushing a toilet and watching the water spin away. He then thought he could create a similar effect except swirling sound, which he theorized would reduce the sound of a gun blast.
- Car mufflers were designed around the same time as gun suppressors and both use many of the same techniques for reducing noise.
|Share the Knowledge!|
When .22 caliber subsonic ammunition is fired through a suppressor with an appropriate number of baffles, the shot is actually very near to silent. I have successfully built and tested 4 such attachments, with diameters ranging from 1 1/4″ to 2″ and lengths of just under 12″ total. All 4 of these were built with standard plumbing parts from your friendly neighborhood hardware store for approximately $20. According to your article, something that is available for hundreds of dollars and requires a $200 minimum non-refundable tax is inferior to something that can be easily built with a little research and ingenuity. Your article may be indicative of larger calibers such as .308 Winchester or .30-06, but any time a subsonic round is used with a silencer, regardless of caliber, there will be no sonic boom, and therefore almost complete silence.
100% agree with you Daniel, my experiences exactly. I have used a couple of different “homemade” silencers on a trusty old Sterling .22 rimfire bolt action repeater rifle, with subsonic ammo. They are as close to silent as you could possibly get with only the sound of the firing pin hitting home and the thud in the distance of the slug hitting it’s target. Most people are amazed at the total silence and hearing the bullet hit.
My Dad first introduced me to the wonders of silencers hunting rabbits as a young boy. We would sneak up on a large number of rabbits and knock down at least half a dozen before any of them had any idea what was happening. I will never forget the confusion of the remaining rabbits as one by one their companions just fell over alongside them.
You are aware that your ‘home built’ suppressors are illegal, and if caught, can get you 30 years in prison, right?
The internet extends well past the borders of the United States.
Bahahaha. Building a suppressor isn’t illegal in many states in the US. Still need to apply with the correct ATF forms, but it’s not illegal. Don’t be an idiot.
The difference is a 22 subsonic is 68db for CCI Quiet even a 10db efficient suppressor will make a sound no louder than a conversaton, a 308 subsonic is around 130-140db (64-128 times louder) a 30db suppressor would reduce it to the level of a power lawn mower, motorcycle, farm tractor, jackhammer or garbage truck.
That 68 decibel rating from CCI is simply false. People I know who have tested it with expensive equipment report it only as low as 111 decibels from a 24″ barrel.
Daniel is correct, and unfortunately, the ATF is currently smashing down his door and tearing apart his home like the SS looking for Anne Franks.
That’s an interesting way to do so, however keep in mind that you just committed a felony by making your own suppressor. So I’d be careful who you’d show and tell that to, as 30 years in prison wouldn’t be fun.
Daniel plz let me no which plumbing parts 2 use
Clearly Daniel didn’t RTFA entirely, or if he did not very closely, OR doesn’t know what “silent” means.
“Silent” doesn’t mean surprisingly not very loud. It means no noise at all, so “very near silent” would be the sound of a page turning in a book or some other extremely quiet sound.
Even typing isn’t “very near silent”.
He is, of course, also a felon but that’s a topic for another comment.
In Army Basic Training, I would be rotated through marking targets on the rifle range. We would be within about six feet of the target center (protected by a dirt berm). The CRACK of the bullet passing through the paper was painfully loud, more so than the actual noise of the weapon firing. No way to silence that!
I spent a good part of my life doing exactly the same thing redstick, usually with .223, 7.62 or .308’s whizzing over my head.
Of course you are right, with anything “super”-sonic there’s no way to silence that sonic boom, not that I’m aware of anyway. Even putting a silencer on a .22 rimfire and then using high velocity, super-sonic ammo, would be a complete, utter waste of time.
But, “sub”-sonic is a completely different story, and with a .22 bolt action rifle, the pin hitting the brass rim of the cartridge IS incredibly quiet, (try dry firing a used cartridge), and that is all you can hear I assure you.
That wasn’t the sound of the round hitting paper, it’s the actual sonic boom of the round passing over head. I know the sound, I was in the Marines. 😉
Your right about the noise down in the “butts”, we were told it was the rounds decelerating slower than the speed of sound…
Dave, I hate to be a buzzkill, but I’ve read four or five of your articles and your grammar is just atrocious. I’m only eighteen, but even I know when to employ the use of a comma. It’s very hard to appear credible as an author on this site when your sentence errors are so common.
Here’s to picking up a copy of The Elements of Style, buddy.
He talk good English, stop tryin to learn us!
Daven*; my apologies.
I have had many years employing different types of suppressors and suppression techniques, on a variety of targets at close range, when noise was a factor in my survival. I will say that “dead silent” is a pun my profession takes to heart. Suppressors CAN be made to fire at decibel levels that will leave the misses in the next room sound asleep. With the use of dampening objects to slow the bullet below sonic speeds (i.e. a telephone book), the suppressor can make your weapon (all the way up to a .38 cal, though .22 subsonic hallows are really the way to go) virtually silent, to the extent that the loudest noise in the room, is the click of the firing pin.. I know this because I know this.
As far as homemade, pvc will outshine any issued suppressor any day.
I (and I’m sure Daniel), would like to politely request that the rest of you armchair ballisticians; and sh#t talkers (lookin’ at you anon), stop stealing our oxygen! …Or atleast learn the subject matter. Have a nice day 🙂
Measurements of loudness are meaningless without an accompanying reference distance; the typical reference distance used is one meter. For example, an ambulance or police siren is typically 100 – 140 db measured at a distance of 1 meter from the siren.
Loudness behaves according to the inverse square law: as the listener get farther away from the source of a sound, the loudness decreases proportionally to the square of that distance.
EXCELLENT ARTICLE. SCIENTIFIC YET EASY ON A LAYMAN. TNX DAVEN
Hi, I have .22Meg, home made silencer but the issue is when we fir into the sky its silent zero noise but if fired straight or in the mountains it still sounds quite high, why is it happening.. can anyone suggest
Please don’t fire guns into the sky. That bullet has to come down somewhere. We have a neighbor kid with a hole in arm because she caught someone else’s bullet.
Daniel, what you are describing is a trip to the federal country for about ten years. I have an ATF agent that would like to talk to you about your building suppressors without a tax stap.
Helloooo…. Earth to Prime! Who cares what the ATF thinks about some kid hunting rabbits? The government is the biggest violator of US gun laws around. (Or US laws in general, if you want to be pedantic.) Remember operation Fast and Furious, where the trustworthy Feds shipped thousands of full auto assault rifles to Mexican Cartels, completely in violation of the law? Or Hurricane Katrina, where the National Guard illegally confiscated householders’s lawfully owned guns, leaving the householders defenseless against looters? But you want to mess with a country kid hunting rabbits with a .22 plinking gun. Right.
Just try and stop us, Prime! I’ve built ten silencers this morning, and fitted them to the toaster, the refrigerator, and the baby stroller. I’m about to fit one to the dog, because then it’s butt will truly be silent but deadly. Ha-ha-ha!
Up yours and your ATF Agent friend. Shall not be infringed. Bitch.
In my readings of WW2, some of the operatives in the South Pacific who operated behind the lines against the Japanese speak of the Welrod pistol. The .32 cal version sounded like a matchstick breaking and that it was very accurate. That is pretty damn quiet, especially around paranoid sentries. Range is only about 50. I looked up Welrod under another source and it says the degree of quiet is still classified. I guess for what it was used for it was a winner.
So in the shooter gaming, silencer that makes gun and rifles sound become ‘phew phew’, rather than ‘bang bang’, is not correct. Thanks for the info
I’m pleased to see someone outside the firearms community pointing out the obvious. They are suppressors, not silencers as portrayed by movie ‘hit men’.
“200 dB is 1000 times louder than 100 dB, not double, and a reduction of 40 dB is more like 1/100th of the original sound.”
Your math doesn’t hold up here. If 40dB is a 100x factor in a logarithmic scale, then 80dB would be (100)^2 = 10,000x factor. So a 100dB difference (200dB-100dB) would be even more than that.
As at least one other have alluded to (but still didn’t appreciate fully) below, the logarithmic scale between 100dB and 200dB is on the order of ten magnitudes of ten, or 10 to the power 10, or 10,000,000,000. Anything above 194dB is when a sound wave becomes a shock wave capable of destroying structures (and bodies). Gun freaks will quibble over a word like “silencer” and then reveal to us that they know nothing about the measurement of sound loudness. Mythbusters did a show on suppresors and were surprised to learn that the movie version of what they do to a gunshot’s noise is surprisingly accurate.
There is no such thing as a ‘silencer’, that’s a term IDIOTS use, and a suppressor is a SUPPRESSOR, not a ‘suppressor’, and most certainly is the latter term NOT an alternative term for the former, as the former is COMPLETE NONSENSE AND ONLY USED BY MORONS. Other than that, pretty accurate.
Frankie, the original name marketed by maxim’s son who invented the damn thing is ‘SILENCER’,
that is what the patent reads. So it IS called a silencer even though it only suppresses the sound and not silences it. The only time a official document called it a suppressor is in some patent in 1985, but the original name given to it by it’s inventor in SILENCER
That’s cause you’re not using subsonic ammunition idiot