Hall of Famer Richie Ashburn Once Struck a Spectator with Foul Balls Twice in the Same At Bat, the Second Time as She was Being Carried Off on a Stretcher

Today I found out Hall of Famer Richie Ashburn once struck a spectator twice in the same at bat with foul balls, the second time as she was being carried off on a stretcher.

The event happened on August 17, 1957 during a game between the Philadelphia Phillies and the New York Giants.  The spectator was Alice Roth.  Roth was the wife of Earl Roth who was an editor for Philadelphia’s Bulletin newspaper, which Ashburn himself would later write for, along with the Philadelphia Daily News.  During the at bat, Ashburn hit a foul ball that struck Roth squarely in the face, breaking her nose.  The game was then paused as medics came in to tend to Roth.  As they were carrying her away on a stretcher, play was resumed and Ashburn fouled off the first pitch thrown to him.  This foul subsequently struck Roth as she was being carried off by the medics.

From that game on, Roth chose to sit in the left field bleachers, far away from any potential foul balls.  Roth and Ashburn became friends after that and Roth’s son eventually got to be a batboy for the Phillies.

Ashburn, by the way, went 2-4 in that game with a double and a single. The Phillies ended up winning it 3-1.

After his playing career was over, Ashburn became an announcer for the Phillies starting in 1963, a job which he kept until 1997.  He had planned to retire in 1997, but he died of a heart attack after a game against the Mets at Shea Stadium on September 9, 1997.

While announcing during home games, Ashburn would sometimes ask if anyone from nearby Celebre’s Pizza wouldn’t mind sending him over a free pizza.  Because Celebre’s was not an official sponsor of the Phillies, the organization made him stop.  To get around this, he would sometimes include with the birthday/anniversary wishes things like: “…special birthday wish to the Celebre’s twins, Plain & Pepperoni” to try to get them to send him a pizza.

Bonus Facts:

  • Richie Ashburn was eventually inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1995 after a campaign by fans with the slogan: “Richie Ashburn, Why the Hall Not?”  Ashburn had this to say about his election: “I’m flattered that so many baseball people think I’m a Hall of Famer. But what’s hard to believe is how one-hundred and fifty plus people have changed their minds about me since I became eligible, because I haven’t had a base hit since then.”
  • Ashburn finished out his career with the expansion New York Mets who only won 40 games that season, which is still a record low to this day.  He performed well, batting .306 with a .428 on base percentage, but ultimately decided to retire. Ashburn was voted the MVP of that team, to which he stated: “MVP on the worst team ever? I wonder what exactly they meant by that?”
  • Ashburn is said to have had difficulties with calling off shortstop Elio Chacón on pop flies because Chacón didn’t speak much English.  To get around this, Ashburn was told to yell “Yo la tengo” (I’ve got it).  When he tried this, however, left fielder Frank Thomas (no, not that Frank Thomas) ran into him.  After the collision, Thomas is said to have asked him “What the heck is a Yellow Tango?”
  • Ashburn was the last Philadelphia Phillie to get eight hits in a single day (during a double header on May 20, 1951).  He hit eight singles on the afternoon, going 4 for 6 and 4 for 5, with one walk in each of the games and two RBIs apiece.  The Phillies lost the first game 3-5 and won the second 9-5, both were against the Brooklyn Dodgers.
  • Ashburn’s longtime announcing partner and hall of fame broadcaster Harry Kalas also died from heart problems.  Rather than after the game like Ashburn, Kalas collapsed in the press box shortly before a game between the Nationals and the Phillies on April 13, 2009.
  • In tribute to Ashburn, the Phillies have named the center-field entertainment area “Ashburn Alley” at Citizen’s Bank Park.  They also named the radio broadcast booth “The Richie ‘Whitey’ Ashburn Broadcast Booth”.  The former of these was named such after fans called for the stadium itself to be renamed in Ashburn’s honor, he having devoted 47 years of his life to the Phillies.
  • If Ashburn had a good day at the plate with a particular bat, he liked to continue to use that bat in subsequent days as long as he was doing well.  As a result of this, he used to bring the bat home with him to make sure the clubhouse attendants didn’t mix it in with his other bats.  According to Ashburn, he would sleep with the bats in his bed.  This prompted him to quip on the air: “I’ve slept with a lot of old bats.”
  • Ashburn was an above average hitter compiling a lifetime line of a .308 batting average and a .396 on base percentage.  He also was known for being an exceptional defensive center fielder.
  • Also in 1957, the Dodgers purchased an airplane to fly their team around during the season.  This made them the first ever Major League Baseball team to do so.
Expand for References:
Share the Knowledge! FacebooktwitterredditpinteresttumblrmailFacebooktwitterredditpinteresttumblrmail
Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Enjoy this article? Join over 50,000 Subscribers getting our FREE Daily Knowledge and Weekly Wrap newsletters:

Subscribe Me To:  | 


  • Whitey was a great athlete. He was an all-state running back. He won the Nebraska state High School 100 yard dash. While in Philly he won the state racquet ball championship. He was a fist class tennis player.

    As I recall, he retired with the best Center Field fielding percentage in the history of baseball.

    In 1958 he beat out Willie Mays for the National League batting title, hitting .353. When he went to General Manager John Quinn to negotiate his 1959 contract, Quinn wanted him to take a pay cut. When Richie asked him why, Quinn said, ‘You don’t hit your hits far enough’. Richie replied: “If I hit them any farther, they’d be outs.”

  • I also recall that after winning the batting title, a reporter asked Richie if he felt cheated that he was not voted the NL MVP. “Nah,” he replied in that great “aw shucks” Nebraska way of his, “the way I figure it, the Phillies could have finished in last place just as well without my help as they did with it!”